M-bar
Technologies and
Consulting, LLC

 

 

 

 

 

 

Joseph W. Mitchell, Ph. D.
760-703-7521

 

 

 

Follow me on Twitter     

For information on WEEDS - the Wind-Enabled Ember-Dousing System -

cedar aftermath

WEEDS Info

Wildland Fire

Power Lines and Fire

Contact Us






Photos courtesy of Nanette Martin

 

WEEDS Information

 

Designing a WEEDS system

September, 2009

 

New WEEDS installation in Descanso, CA

April, 2011

 

WEEDS featured on 10News San Diego                                Quicktime Movie (145 MB)

Broadcast 9/23/2009.  Quicktime video courtesy of 10News.

 

 

 

Presentation on WEEDS and comparison to other structure protection techniques

Prepared for the Ramona Fire Recovery Center, 8/12/2008

 

 

 

 

 

Presentation to the Fire & Materials 2007 Conference (web version, only works with IE):  
   Powerpoint presentation for download  
   Accompanying Article (.pdf)      Extended Abstract (.pdf) 
("Firebrand Protection as the Key Design Element for Structure Survival during Catastrophic Wildland Fires", Co-authored with Oren Patashnik and containing statistical results on curved-tile roofing. Presented Jan. 31, 2007 in San Francisco)

 

 

 

Presentation to the Third International Fire Ecology and Management Conference (web version, only works with IE)

 

(Powerpoint presentation for download)    -  Presented in San Diego on November 17, 2006 in the Wildland-Urban Interface Track.

 

 

 

The Fire Safety Journal  - An academic article on WEEDS has been published in the September 2006 edition (Subscription required for full download, available free of charge at many university libraries.)

 

 

 

WILDFIRE Magazine Article - Here are some references for the WEEDS article in the March 2005 edition

 

 

 

Home&fire Magazine - Spring 2005 edition contains WEEDS: Wind Enabled Ember Dousing System. p. 32

 

 

 

Engineering a Miracle - the story of WEEDS (published in The San Diego Reader, April 29, 2004)

 

 

 

 

Wildland Fire

 

 

Wildland fire still an unsolved problem

Commentary in the Ramona Sentinel, 7/23/2009.

 

California Office of the State Fire Marshal Task Force on Wildfire Protection Building Construction

Assisted the State Fire Marshal’s Office in establishing a framework for testing ignition-resistant construction proposed for the 2010 update to the California Building Code, Chapter 7A.  Final draft 5/21/2009.

Chapter 7A Task Force Recommendations                State Fire Marshal Test Standards Task Force Recommendations

 


 

 


 

Union Tribune Op-ed on SD County's "Shelter-in-Place" Guidelines - May 5, 2007

 

 

 

Power Lines and Wildland Fire


The Proposed Utility "Wildfire Expense Balancing Account


In 2009, California electrical utilities PG&E, SCE and SDG&E proposed creating a formal mechanism through which they could recover liability losses from wildland fires from ratepayers regardless of whether or not they were responsible for starting the fires. MGRA and other parties oppose this proposal, noting that it creates a moral hazard by reducing incentive for safe operation.

MGRA Testimony

served September 11, 2011



Proposed changes to California power line safety regulations

The 2008-2011 rulemaking instituted by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) is intended to make changes to current California regulations in order to reduce the likelihood of power line fire ignitions in hazard areas. Several rules were introduced by MGRA including:

  • Ensuring that utilities have contingency plans in place for extreme Santa Ana events.
  • Requiring that utilities collect data on power line fire ignitions and share it with the CPUC (co-sponsored with Consumer Protection and Safety Division (CPSD).
  • Sponsoring the creation of hazard maps that include areas with high winds during Santa Ana events for the use of utilities in planning (co-sponsored with CPSD in consultation with Cal Fire).

Comments on the Proposed Decisions              Reply Comments                   Final Decision by the Commission

 

Goaded into Action: California's Regulatory Response to the Power Line Fire Threat

Presented at the 5th Annual Wildland Fire Litigation Conference, April 16, 2011



January 2010 Submission to the Victorian Royal Bushfires Commission

This submission describes current academic work as well as activities before the California Public Utilities Commission on powerlines and wildland fire.  Five of the eleven “Black Saturday” fires under investigation by the Royal Bushfires Commission were reportedly due to power line ignitions.

 

The September 2009 CPUC Decision on the SDG&E Shut-Off Plan

Proposed decisions were issued in August. Comments and reply comments opposing the shut-off plan were filed on behalf of MGRA. The cost/benefit analysis initially proposed by M-bar Technologies and Consulting, LLC and other issues raised in our filings were cited as a key reasons for the Commission denial of the SDG&E shut-off plan.

Comments on the Proposed Decisions              Reply Comments                   Final Decision by the Commission

 

Additional Comments Regarding SDG&E Shut-Off plan

Filed 5/26/2009 on behalf of MGRA and at the behest of the Administrative Law Judge, this contains additional calculations suggesting that the SDG&E shut-off criteria have been set too low.

 


 

 


San Diego Union Tribune Op-Ed: The PUC should deny this plan outright

May 10th, 2009 – Co-authored with Diane Conklin. Discusses how the potential hazards and costs of the SDG&E shut-off plan outweigh its benefits under any but the most extreme conditions. This was paired with a “Pro” column by SDG&E CEO Debra Reed.

 

 

 

When to Turn Off the Power? Cost/Benefit Outline for Proactive De-energization

Filed with the CPUC in response to SDG&E’s 2008 application A.08-12-021 to turn off power under Santa Ana conditions, filed 3/27/2009 on behalf of MGRA. Turning off the power increases other types of risk – including fire risk. Benefits of turning off the power during high-wind conditions have to be weighed against costs & risks, which should result in an optimal shut-off threshold.

 

 

 

“Power Lines and Catastrophic Wildland Fire in Southern California” Presentation to the Fire & Materials 2009 Conference, San Francisco CA, Jan 26, 2009

Paper                      PowerPoint Presentation

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

MGRA Phase 2 Testimony to the Califonia Public Utilities Commission on San Diego Gas & Electric's Proposed "Sunrise Powerlink" Transmission Line
- The analysis for MGRA continues, with powerline contributions from the October 2007 fires, an anomalously high number of power line fires in San Diego County, implications of another 230 kV fire in 2007, and some inconsistent SDG&E wind calculations.
Submitted 3/12/2008. Published online at the request of the MGRA.

 

 

 

 

 

MGRA Phase 1 Testimony to the Califonia Public Utilities Commission on San Diego Gas & Electric's Proposed "Sunrise Powerlink" Transmission Line
- An analysis of powerline fires and the wind events that both cause them and make them more destructive than other wildland fires. Submitted 5/31/2007.

 

 

 

For more information, contact:






M-bar Technologies and Consulting, LLC
19412 Kimball Valley Rd.
Ramona, CA 92065
760-703-7521


Last update 12/18/2011